The Taxing Wealth Report 2024 suggests that wealth in the UK might be undertaxed by up to £170 billion a year when compared to income in a new report published this morning:
This suggestion is explained in a report of 5,300 words. The brief summary says:
This note suggests that, based on a review of taxes paid, UK national income and changes in UK wealth from 2011 to 2020:
- The UK has a tax system on income that is regressive at the lowest levels of income, broadly flat over the middle range of UK incomes, and is only slightly progressive at the upper end, without however replicating on highest incomes the tax rates paid by those on lowest income.
- Has a very generous system of taxation on wealth that means that whereas income was on average taxed at 32.9 per cent over this period, increases in wealth were only taxed at 4.1 per cent.
- The combined average tax rate on income and increases in wealth over this period amounted to 25.6 per cent per annum.
- Because of the way in which wealth is distributed in the UK, with most being owned by the top ten per cent of the population, this differential in tax rates means that the UK actually has a deeply regressive tax system.
- Those with lowest income in the UK were likely to have a combined tax rate on income and increases in wealth of approximately 44 per cent per annum during this period whilst those in the highest decile of earners in the UK were likely to pay no more than 21.5 per cent per annum on their combined income and increase in wealth.
- If the tax rates on income and increases in wealth were equalised then additional tax revenue of £170 billion a year might be raised in the UK as a result.
What this suggests is that:
- There is significant additional capacity to tax in the UK, although only from those with most income and wealth.
- A strong case for reducing the tax paid by those on lowest incomes can be made.
- On balance, so long as additional sources of tax revenue are charged only (or almost entirely) on those with the highest income in the UK then there is no reason for any UK government or political party seeking power to suggest that there is no additional capacity to tax in the UK: that capacity very clearly exists.
The Taxing Wealth Report 2024 will explore about thirty ways in which this additional revenue might be raised in ways consistent with these findings.
The unfair UK tax system
The following chart suggests the true scale of the regressivity of the UK's tax system:
Those in the lowest decile of income earners in the UK pay tax at around 44% on their income and gains in financial wellbeing, whilst those in the top decile pay at 21.5%, less than half that rate. That is why there is capacity to raise more tax from wealth in the UK.
The full report that supports this note is available here.